Moral Status: Case Analysis

Student Name:

After reading of the “Case Study: Fetal Abnormality” and the specific moral status theories in the topic Resources, respond to the following prompts, using only citations from the case and topic Resources:

Based on the case and specific moral status theories in the topic Resources, in 450-500 words, what is the Christian view of the nature of human persons, and which theory of moral status is it compatible with? How is this related to the intrinsic human value and dignity?

Based on the case, in 200-250 words,which specific moral status theory or theories from the topic Resources are being used by Jessica, Marco, Maria, and Dr. Wilson to determine the moral status of the fetus? What from the case study specifically leads you to believe that they hold the theory or each of the theories you identified?

Based on the case and specific moral status theories in the topic Resources, in 200-250 words,how does the theory or each of the theories they used determine or influence each individual’s recommendation for action?

Based on the case and specific moral status theory or theories from the topic Resources, in 200-250 words,what theory do you personally agree with and why? How would that theory determine or influence your recommended action in a similar situation?

Based on the case and topic Resources, in 200-250 words,how does the integration of knowledge in health care (theories, multiple ways of knowing, evidence) and knowledge from other disciplines inform and support your current or future professional health care practices and judgements regarding moral status issues?

Struggling with where to start this assignment? Follow this guide to tackle your assignment easily!

Step-by-Step Guide to Structuring and Writing Your Moral Status Case Analysis

Before writing, be sure to thoroughly review the “Case Study: Fetal Abnormality” and the moral status theories in the topic Resources. You’ll need to reference both to support your answers. Write in clear, academic language and stay within the word count guidelines.

1. The Christian View of Human Nature and Moral Status

(450–500 words)

Structure Your Response:

Begin by summarizing the Christian perspective on the human person. Focus on the belief that all human life is sacred and created in the image of God.
Identify the compatible moral status theory: Most often, this aligns with the theory of intrinsic human value, which holds that human beings have moral status by nature, not because of their capacities or functions.
Explain the implications: Because of this intrinsic value, every person—regardless of developmental stage, ability, or condition—is worthy of dignity and respect.
Connect to the fetus in the case study: Highlight that from this view, the fetus is a full human person with moral status, regardless of abnormalities.

Use citations from the topic readings to back this up (e.g., teachings from the Catechism, Christian bioethics articles, etc.).

2. Theories Used by Each Character

(200–250 words)

Structure Your Response:

Jessica: Likely uses a relational theory, focusing on her role as mother and the future implications for her family and child.
Marco: May reflect utilitarianism, balancing consequences like financial and emotional burden.
Maria (the grandmother): Likely holds a theory of intrinsic value or divine command theory, valuing the fetus as a life given by God.
Dr. Wilson: Often aligns with cognitive properties theory or sentience theory, considering the prognosis and quality of life.

Cite specific quotes or behaviors from the case to support your interpretations.

3. Influence of Theories on Recommendations

(200–250 words)

Structure Your Response:

Jessica’s relational concerns influence her indecision—she is torn between love, duty, and potential suffering.
Marco’s utilitarian concerns lead him to consider abortion as a way to reduce long-term burden.
Maria’s religious and intrinsic value stance causes her to oppose abortion entirely, urging the family to trust in God.
Dr. Wilson’s clinical, capacity-based view leads him to present abortion as a reasonable option, focusing on quality of life.

Explain how each individual’s ethical framework leads to their moral recommendation.

4. Your Personal View and Ethical Recommendation

(200–250 words)

Structure Your Response:

State the theory of moral status you agree with (e.g., intrinsic human value, relational, sentience, etc.)
Justify your position—why do you believe this theory offers the best moral guidance?
Apply this to the case: what would your recommended course of action be based on your view?
- For example, if you support intrinsic value, you may recommend carrying the pregnancy to term.
- If you support sentience or cognitive properties theory, you might justify abortion in cases of severe abnormality.

5. Integration of Knowledge into Healthcare Practice

(200–250 words)

Structure Your Response:

Discuss how knowledge from ethical theory, medical evidence, patient narratives, and interdisciplinary studies guides professional practice.
Explain how understanding moral status theories helps healthcare providers make respectful, patient-centered decisions.
Emphasize the importance of compassionate, culturally sensitive care, especially in complex ethical cases like fetal abnormality.
Reflect on how this integration will shape your current or future decision-making, especially when facing patients with diverse worldviews.

Tips for Success:

Stick to the word count ranges.
Use only citations from the case and topic Resources.
Avoid introducing outside opinions or sources.
Maintain an objective, professional tone.
Proofread for clarity and flow.

Would you like help formatting your APA citations for this assignment?

The post Case Study: Fetal Abnormality appeared first on Skilled Papers.