In each response, identify one other way the social worker has self-disclosed in this interview. Explain whether this type of self-disclosure is positive or negative. 150 words for each post and one reference for each.
Ariel Brown
In the “Southside Community Service” video the social workers disclosed to the client that she and her husband and kids had to downgrade to a smaller apartment, but they loved it. According to (Cummings & Sevel, 2017) using self-disclosure appropriately takes time to learn, in part because there are some instances where self-disclosure is necessary and helpful. In this video the social worker disclosed to Mrs. Bargas, and it was a bit of relief. It didn’t create any tension, but it created comfort for the client in her situation. This was purposeful for the client to give her confidence. This was a positive self-disclosure because the social worker showed compassion and empathy. The negative aspects of it could be to cause the client to shut down and it may not be helpful to them at the time. I would have self-disclosed because when I’m talking to people, and they get a sense of the real you it helps create a positive feeling for the client because they know that they’re not alone and they’re not the only one who is going through a situation.
Reference
Cummins, L., K., & Sevel, J., A. (2017). Social work skills for beginning direct practice: Text, workbook, and interactive web based case studies (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education.
Chapter 5, “Basic Skills for Direct Practice” 87-115)
Chapter 7, “Common Errors in Direct Practice” (pp. 135-161)
Walden University, LLC. (Producer). (2016). Southside Community Services: Mrs. Bargas, episode 2[Video file]. Walden University Canvas. https://waldenu.instructure.com/
Cynthia Garrison
When Mrs. Bargas mentions she cannot afford where she and her family are staying, she throws out the idea of moving to a smaller place, but doesn’t seem happy about having to do so. The social worker tries to spin the idea into a positive choice by telling Mrs. Bargas that her and her husband moved into a smaller apartment last year with their two children and they enjoy it. It is less work to keep clean and cheaper. It seemed to help ease Mrs. Bargas worries of space knowing the social worker also has children and is still comfortable living in a smaller apartment. It could be a possible solution for Mrs. Bargas and her family.
It is difficult to see any negative aspects of this disclosure. Disclosing the social workers experience of living in a smaller apartment may not have changed Mrs. Bargas mind about downsizing.
The positive aspect is the social worker has given Mrs. Bargas one solution to her financial struggles. If I have had a similar experience that I think would benefit my client I would definitely disclose that experience with my client to show that they are not alone and to help them with a positive solution to their problem.
Walden University, LLC. (Producer). (2016). Southside Community Services: Mrs. Bargas, episode 2 [Video file]. Walden University Canvas. https://waldenu.instructure.com/
